I received an order Kleenmama hay over a week ago and the rabbits aren't eating it. They're going for the Oxbow. I don't know if it's because they aren't used to it or they don't like it. It does have a lot of brown pieces. But at least it isn't dusty compared to the OxBow. I've had it with that dust. I'm throwing away a good 10% of the bag because of the dust and small, broken up pieces at the bottom.
I got 2nd and 3rd cut hay from Kleenmama's. I see no difference. Also, I bought their new bluegrass/alfalfa blend and it looks exactly like the Timothy hay. No difference and the rabbits aren't eating it either. They usually gobble up anything with alfalfa in it. This is frustrating.
I've never heard of FarmerDave's but I'll check it out online. Thanks SamiJami.